A China patent prior-use defense can protect qualifying earlier manufacturing, method use or necessary preparation, but only continued activity within the original scope. An old business registration or a statement that “we developed it first” does not establish every element. The relevant product or method, date, business entity and production capacity all need attention.
This guide focuses on invention and utility model disputes involving products or processes. It is general information for businesses and their advisers, not a conclusion about a particular patent or factory. Official sources were checked on November 13, 2026.
What does China's prior-use defense cover?
Article 75(2) of the current Patent Law, published by CNIPA addresses manufacturing the same product, using the same method, or making the necessary preparations before the patent application date, followed by manufacturing or use only within the original scope. Establishing this defense does not invalidate the patent or give the prior user an exclusive patent right.
Start by checking the asserted patent and the relevant cutoff. Under Article 12 of the 2023 Patent Law Implementing Regulations, the Patent Law's application date generally means the priority date where priority applies, subject to stated exceptions. Do not automatically use the Chinese publication or grant date. A claimed priority requires review for the subject matter at issue; historical conduct may also require checking the applicable legal version.
What counts as necessary preparation?
Article 15 of the Supreme People's Court patent infringement interpretation recognizes completed principal technical drawings or process documents essential to implementation, or manufacture or purchase of the essential principal equipment or raw materials. It excludes reliance on unlawfully obtained technology or designs. The interpretation's older reference to Article 69(2) corresponds to the current Article 75(2). Its November 2026 webpage date is a republication date, not a new prior-use rule.
For an initial evidence review, create a chronology that connects each record to the actual technical solution and the business claiming the defense:
Identify the relevant drawing or process version, its creator and lawful technical origin; preserve the original files and change history.
Connect equipment or materials records to specifications, orders, delivery, installation and the intended manufacturing process, as available.
Match trial-production records, samples and inspection reports to the same product version and dates.
Record which legal entity performed each activity. A parent, subsidiary, supplier and distributor should not be treated as interchangeable names.
Separate contemporaneous records from later summaries. Preserve originals and explain who created a later compilation and which earlier records support it.
This is a practical organization method, not a prescribed evidentiary formula. A generic machine invoice may identify a purchase without showing the relevant technical preparation. A file's displayed creation date may need corroboration; do not alter or backdate records to fill a gap.
Why do the actor and completed activity matter?
In (2020) Supreme People's Court IP Civil Appeal No. 1158, decided in December 2021 and published in February 2022, the court rejected a prior-use defense on the evidence before it. Its analysis addressed inadequately corroborated internal production records, research completed after the cutoff, records concerning other entities, and insufficient preparation for the accused pharmaceutical manufacture.
The decision illustrates why evidence must prove the relevant proposition, not merely carry an earlier date. It does not mean every internal record is inadmissible or that every industry must complete pharmaceutical approval steps. For a manufacturing business, explain what was actually completed, by whom, and how it relates to the activity now challenged.
How far can production continue?
The interpretation defines original scope to include the production scale already existing before filing and the scale achievable using existing equipment or preparations. It is therefore broader than simply repeating the exact number of units previously sold, while still requiring a supported capacity boundary.
Prepare a before-and-after capacity file: relevant machines, tooling, process versions, available production arrangements, contemporaneous capacity calculations and subsequent additions. Distinguish output attainable from earlier preparations from output dependent on later investment. A later production line or changed process needs its own assessment; a company-wide turnover figure cannot answer that technical question.
For example, a business might have dated drawings and one installed assembly cell before the relevant cutoff, then add another cell later. Review the capacity supported by the earlier cell and preparations separately from the later addition. This hypothetical is an evidence-planning example, not a conclusion that either cell qualifies or a fixed expansion allowance.
Can another company inherit or license the defense?
The interpretation generally rejects extending the defense through post-filing transfers or licenses of the earlier technology or design, with an exception when it is transferred or inherited together with the original enterprise. An ordinary technology license should not be assumed to carry that exception.
Before a restructuring, acquisition or manufacturing handover, preserve the entity history, transaction documents and records of the relevant operations. Ask for a specific assessment of the proposed arrangement rather than assuming common ownership passes the defense throughout a corporate group.
Frequently asked questions
Must the earlier technical records have been public?
Prior use and prior art address different questions. Private manufacturing or preparation records may be relevant to prior use; their confidentiality alone does not make them proof of public disclosure. For public technical disclosures, see our China patent prior-art defense guide.
Is a supplier invoice enough?
Identify what it proves: goods purchased, the actor, timing, or a particular preparation. A seller's argument about purchased goods may instead raise the separate patent lawful-source defense. Do not treat those defenses as interchangeable.
Should confidential drawings be sent with the first inquiry?
Start with the public patent number, the parties' names, a public product link, the China-related issue, budget and expected timing. Before sharing unpublished technology or private case files, arrange conflict checks, confidentiality terms and an appropriate secure channel.
For help organizing a China patent dispute inquiry, visit our IP enforcement and dispute services. Preserve the existing evidence and seek a case-specific assessment before relying on continued production or a transfer arrangement.
